Nice and tidy green plan. But will the best possible solution be found by someone drawing lines on paper half a country away from the golf course, months before a single shovel of dirt is moved? Will the builder see this drawing as the architect does? No chance, as we are all influenced by our experiences.
What happens when a builder follows the eye of the plan and builds those dome like mounds as they are drawn? What happens when the architect doesn't like what is built and makes some suggestions, then leaves the site for weeks as the machine operator works in his absence. Will he do the job as the absent architect envisioned the second time? Is this the best way to build a greensite? No. But it is the standard method of building greens all over the world. Standard does not mean best; not by miles.
Hear me out... this is the short version...
If there isn't a natural green in the landscape, or one requiring just a bit of obvious alteration, an architect has to design one. What I prefer to do is estimate the amount of material required for the hole at hand, and draw concepts. Lots of concepts.
If need be, I'll keep drawing right up to the day the green is to be built. These drawing are ideas, general guidelines. By the time the day comes to shape the subgrade of the green, I have settled on a concept and set to work. Usually when tooling around, shaping the green I'll hit on something that alters it. This is a good thing, like sculpting clay. I get the best out of what is there, and detail I could never have drawn on paper, or imagined at the drawing board.
The problem with planning a green out inch by inch are multiple:
1. Architects are not omnipotent...
2. It takes longer to build.
3. Some just don't fit into the landscape as well as they should and because someone is creating the product absent of the architect they don't want to deviate because it could cost them and their company. Maybe the architect was looking for something special to him... and the builder just doesn't get it. How would the builder know?
4. What happens when an alteration is made to one green, one which should require an alteration to another green or greens so the holes or greens don't look or play similar? Those plans start to look less and less important.
The ability to change direction on a dime, to be flexible, to seek the best solution is not only faster... it produces a better product.
Not everything should be planned if it can be worked out in the field... or according to the great golf architect Einstein, "not everything that counts can be counted."
INSERT SEQUENCE OF SKETCHES
Tony Ristola
agolfarchitect.com
agolfarchitect@yahoo.com
+49 (0)173 450 4552
+1(909) 581 0080
